Written by Raymond Nakamura
Once upon a time, Raymond earned his doctorate studying the hydrodynamics of sand dollars. Nowadays, when he’s not employed as personal assistant to his lovely and demanding daughter, he enjoys creating fun and educational experiences in science and history using facts and fiction, words, pictures and whatever else is handy. Follow him on Twitter @raymondsbrain

Created date

Thursday, July 14, 2011 - 9:23pm

How do seedless watermelons get that way?

My daughter loves watermelon and I was thinking she was getting big enough to have a seed spitting contest. But watermelon seeds seem to be vanishing. I'm used to seedless grapes but only recently became aware of this watermelon situation. Seedless watermelons have been growing in popularity since 1990. From the standpoint of a plant, the whole point of fruit is produce seeds, so I wondered what kind of hanky panky was going on to produce seedless watermelons. Turns out that they are like mules, self-sterile hybrids and involve a lot of work.


Watermelon plants are usually diploid, like us, meaning they have two sets of chromosomes, the packages of DNA with instructions for life.


Seedless watermelons are triploid. They have three sets of chromosomes. This odd number results in them being sterile and not producing seeds. The way they become triploid is by mating a diploid male with a tetraploid female. Tetraploids have four sets of chromosomes.


The way you get tetraploids is by applying a chemical called colchicine which messes with cells as they are dividing. You add it to diploid seedlings and then some cells become tetraploid. You have to cultivate these over several generations to get enough that produce enough viable seeds with suitable traits.

Mixing It Up

Watermelon plants have male flowers and female flowers. The female flowers have a little pea-sized melon behind it. You remove the male flowers on the tetraploid plants because the female tetraploid flowers produce triploid fruit. It doesn't work with a male tetraploid and female diploid. Pollination can be done by hand or using bees.

Go Time

Seeds from the triploid fruit grow into triploid plants. They don't produce much pollen, so you plant some diploid plants. This pollen stimulates the triploid female flowers to produce fruit. Because the number of chromosomes is not compatible, they don't have seeds.

The seedless watermelons are smaller and rounder. They are supposed to be sweeter and last longer. But do you think it's really worth all the extra work?


No, not really. As much fun

No, not really. As much fun as it is to have a seedless melon, getting to spit watermelon seeds is part of the fun.

well, I'd have to agree, my

well, I'd have to agree, my kids do like seedless watermelons ok, but they do like the whole spitting the seeds thing.

I absolutely hate seedless (?

I absolutely hate seedless (?) watermelon. I am not particularly fond of all the little white seeds. I would much rather have something I can get rid of. I also don't like these cone shapes that appear in seedless. They just seem to be something that doesn't belong there. If the melon is good and ripe, I pluck them out while eating and throw them away. So much for science!!

I know right the seedless

I know right the seedless variety are so mushy no crunch at all.

Personally I haven't noticed

Personally I haven't noticed the seedless watermelons tasting any sweeter than other watermelons. If anything, they're more watery and have less flavor, plus those nasty little white seeds. I never picked out the larger black seeds in regular watermelons, I always just ate them. They tasted like those roasted pumpkin seeds you can get on Halloween so every summer I'd look forward to the seeds. Now I'm lucky if I can even find a regular watermelon anymore. The regular ones are bigger, taste better and I honestly see no reason why seedless melons were introduced in the first place. I do think the process of growing the seedless ones is kind of interesting, though. It seems more unnecessary than anything else. A waste of time, effort and money. There's also the nostalgia of having the seeds in a watermelon, the way they were years ago. It's just a part of summer, having seed-spitting contests or planting the seeds in the garden or saving them or what have you. I think seedless watermelons are an American thing (though it's spreading to Canada). I haven't seen seedless melons in Europe or the Caribbean yet.

what two or three ways do

what two or three ways do watermelon become seedless

how could anyone think that

how could anyone think that chemically messing with the DNA of the watermelon, creating mutant chromosomes, and breeding them could possibly be a good thing and something you want to put in your body?!? just like the article started a fruit is the part of the plant that contains the seeds. That's natural! So get over it chew them, swallow them, or spit them out! be healthy.

Traditional breeding messes

Traditional breeding messes with the DNA, assuming by 'messing with' you mean altering. Evolution has been doing it for millions of years, so I don't see why humans can't. If we hadn't been messing with DNA, aka artificial selection, we would be eating small, tasteless, and in some cases poisonous, food items. Compare corn with teosinte for example.

Seedless watermelons, even

Seedless watermelons, even organic ones, make me nauseated and occasionally cause vomiting. The black seeded, or regular, watermelons never to that to me. They also have a lot of flavor, whereas the seedless watermelons are just colored water, no flavor at all.

These "seedless" watermelons

These "seedless" watermelons leave an unpleasant after taste about one hour later. I DO NOT BUY them anymore. Chemicals do it, NOT ".... ploids". Besides they have some fully grown seeds... How do they explain this? During my lifetime I have eaten thousands of watermelons and grape seeds. I think seedless fruits were created for LAZY PEOPLE !


Add comment